So I ordered these twice. First time I order 6 packs and I got a really great deal because the employee ( or whoever) gave me two of each color! 100 orange, 100 blue, and a 100 green. I was pretty happy when I saw that! So I figured I should try my luck again. This time I went for 10, hoping for 5 sets of different colors. Instead I got all green. All 10 packs of sleeves were green. So I have 500 more green sleeves! O joy.... Overall a great deal. Just hope you get a good person setting up your order!

  -- By Dustin from Gainesville, Virginia on January 26, 2012

Absolutely, you can't beat the price for sleeves. I asked for all purple and got it, roughly 20% of the sleeves I received were defective, but I still received enough to case 8 decks. Don't order this if you want tournament legal sleeves, don't expect anything good if you don't leave comments on your order to your preferences for colors or doubles on 50 packs.

  -- By Nick Conroy from Pittsburgh/Philly PA on October 05, 2011

I bought 10 packs, got 10 50 count legends metallic. They're not good quality, they're not tournament legal, but they are 75 cents. You get what you pay for, and the price is really unbeatable.

  -- By daniel from San Diego, CA on September 27, 2011

I order five of them to see what I could get, I got so so at best sleeves with the five I order. But that dose not mean I'm not happy with the order after all they are only $0.75 each so I plan to use them for drafts.

  -- By Michael from Aloha, OR on September 05, 2011

It is a great buy. A friend and i split an order of 14 packs. We got 5 Orange 1 Red 1 Blue 6 Grey and 1 Purple. I dont care that they were all the same holographic design. But it is a very good buy.

  -- By Randy Row from Red Oak, TX on August 01, 2011

I ordered 12 at 75 cents each. They were all Legends metallic/shiny packs of 50 solid color. I asked for duplicates of two and got 3 red, 1 silver, 2 green, 2 blue, 2 orange, 2 purple. They are pretty durable as far as i can tell (only played with them for 1 night. They sometimes have a little glue along the edges but nothing major as it can be peeled off easily. Non were bent as in other comments. I don't think i can use them in drafts because they are shiny (will try anyways) but it's definitely an amazing price when starting out magic without sleeves.

  -- By James Scott from Arkansas on July 23, 2011

Ordered 15, got 11 of these packs (I got a bonus in M:TG cards instead), 50 sleeves each, holo-background. Asked for dupes, got 3pack*1color, 2p*3c, 1p*2color. Some were curled in their package, but they straighten up as soon as they have a card in them or are in a deck box. Awesome price, Great quality, and they get the job done! Thanks T&T!

  -- By Aris from Rochester, NH USA on May 07, 2011

got four differant colors all 50 packs but holografic :) can't beat the price plan on buying lots more

  -- By Jesse from NY on April 20, 2011

Ordered 8 and included a note in the order to provide matched pairs if possible. I received all 50 packs of Legends Card Protectors. 6 out of the 8 were matching sets, 2 purple and 4 black/silver and they may have tried for all, but the last two were red and dark orange. I had to double-take to check myself. They have a neat holographic/metallic design on the back. I also purchased some Ultra•PRO sleeves and, in comparison, they are not as pretty, but I prefer them due to being slightly thicker and having textured backs that are less prone to stick together and not show scratches as easily. I only have just received both types so can't compare their durability.

  -- By Jay Hajj from Holiday, FL on March 31, 2011

The sleeves pretty much suck, but they are only 99 cents. Every set that I got was a 50 sleeve set, so, for Magic you will hope to get multiples of the same color. I ordered them 6 at a time and usually got a mixture of 2-3 colors. Some of the sleeves have flaws and oddities about them and you have to toss some out, but the cost makes them worth the purchase. I'm not into paying $10 for a set of sleeves.

  -- By Preston Wiley from Indiana on March 30, 2011

I loved it: bought 20 packs and got them just perfect. All have 50 sleeves each. They came basically in 5 different colors and all but one had more than two packs. Sure gonna buy some more on my next shipment.

  -- By Renato from Florianópolis, SC Brazil on March 28, 2011

I ordered 30 packs along with a total of 10,000 Magic cards from the random lots, and was expecting the majority of them to be YGO size. Since I play both, it wouldn't have been so bad, but I was hoping I'd get some Magic sleeves since I already have a great deal of YGO size sleeves. Evidently someone at trollandtoad loves me, because all 30 sleeves were Magic size, exactly what I needed! Thx so much Trollandtoad. The sleeves I recieved were the cheap Legends sleeves in all 6 colors, multiples of each, perfect for sideboards. For the price, how can you possibly complain? Some people obviously have no idea that you are paying $1 for a random pack of sleeves. If you had your heart set on a certain type of sleeve, why not pay the price for it? Thx again, trollandtoad, I only joined back in Janurary and I can tell you now I will be a constant returning customer!

  -- By Francisco Rosario from Brooklyn, NY on March 10, 2011

I purchased 35. All were Legends Supplies, With Shiny/Foil-looking backs. None had art, all were packs of 50. I was happy that they (mostly) came in pairs (or more) so that I was not stuck with singletons of 50 packs. However, all are the same. Furthermore, the Legends Supplies sleeves have fringe in the bottom seal (making them "marked"), and are all shiny (so are "distracting"), so none of them are tournament legal. Am I disappointed? Not really. They were cheap, undamaged and none were penny sleeves. I can trade them, or use them for EDH. Am I happy I did it? Again not really. Except for a minor variation of color all were the same, and none were tournament legal, rendering my plan to have a bunch of sleeves sitting around for tournaments, moot. Will I do it again? No. Not with sleeves. This is a way for T&T to empty their warehouse. THIS IS NOT RANDOM. It improbable/bordering on impossible for a randomizing computer to select all of the same type of sleeves with this sample size. You WILL NOT get a random selection of everything on the site, only a semi-random selection of the items they have over-stocked.

  -- By Gary Peter from Pittsburgh on March 02, 2011

I ordered ten and asked for five doubled sets if possible in my order comments, and got exactly that, in a rainbow of shiny holo-design. I love bright colors, so that was right up my alley. A pair of 100-packs in the order would have been even more exciting, but I'm pleased as punch, regardless. :)

  -- By Lauren Kuklis from Eastern Pennsylvania, US on February 22, 2011

Really should be 3.5 stars, but I'm giving T&T the benefit of the extra star because they're awesome otherwise. Because another reviewer reported that some packs were bent, I ordered 10 to be sure that if some were bent or defective, I could just toss them. I have 2 minor complaints: 1--all of mine are in packs of 50. Since a deck is at least 60, that is a problem. I got two packs of 3 colors which is perfect, but only 1 pack of the others. Still, no biggie. 2. My second complaint is also minor--they are all metallic/hologrammy. Since the fronts are NOT holograms, I don't really care. Card protection for less than a buck. So order 2-3 times more than you need, to be sure you get at least 60 of a color. Or just order specific ones and pay a lot more. :) Either way, everybody wins.

  -- By Mr Pendent from Austin, TX on February 10, 2011

These sleeves are perfect for casual play. I even asked politely to get matching packs to sleeve some EDH commander decks and they were able to do it. I ordered 20 packs and got 2-3 packs of 6 different colors of holo sleeves (some slightly bent, but nothing a book wont fix to flatten out) This is a super deal for the cost.

  -- By Joseph Correa from Indiana on February 10, 2011

You can't beat the price for these. I ordered 10 of these and requested to have enough of the same colored sleeve to make 60 card decks with a 15 card sideboard. I recieved 2 blue 2 orange 2 purple 2 green and 2 red 50ct sleeves with all the same holofoil design. They all were slightly bent, some more than others but all should do fine for causal play. I wouldnt recommend these for tournament play on account of the condition, but for causal play you simply cant beat the price. Fully sleeving a deck for under 2 bucks is a steal! I look forward to getting more of these in the future to see what i snag next time!

  -- By Anonymous from Spruce Pine, NC on January 27, 2011

i ordere 10 before...put n comments needed at least 2 of each color cuz of 60 card decks..i got 3 orange 3 blue 3 purple and 1 silverish color.....i wwas very happy with these....i had ordered 1000 of the clear ones from somewhere else but am very unhappy with those...i just ordered 40 more of these...will post after i get them....im overall very happy with my experiences with these guys....eveb over the phone....only had one person that wasnt as helpful as culd of been but i wont hold my experience against them for that one time... enjoy ur games!

  -- By Amber from MA on January 04, 2011

This is the greatest disappointment I've had in Troll and Toad. I read all the reviews, some good, some bad, but all assuring random packs with little duplicates. Even the picture shows a wider variety than what I got. What I thought would be a good deal turned out to be a complete load of crap. I ordered 50 of these thinking I'd get some good quality and maybe some ok sleeves at a great price, What I got were the cheapest sleeves anyone could possibly make. All of them were Legends card sleeves in all 6 metallic colors. Beat and bent to hell from the start, I'll never be able to use these. None of them are even cut right, They all have flaps of melted plastic on the sides and bottom and are warped towards the edges. Again I am very disappointed with Troll and Toad and will never buy these again without the guarantee of better quality.

  -- By Michael Farra from Aloha, OR USA on December 28, 2010

I had my reserves about these but ordered six anyway. Tried asking for pairings in the comments section as some others have suggested, still ended up with all different colors. Probably won't try it again, great deal... but I'd pay a couple bucks more for the guarantee that they'll be useful.

  -- By Jerry from Vegas on November 20, 2010

For the value you can't really go wrong, the only problem is they only come in packs of 50 when a deck is 60 cards, but just order a bunch since they are cheap and hope you get some of the same :)

  -- By Benjamen from Canada on November 15, 2010

Just got mine in yesterday.... Ordered 10 packs and listed in the comments section that I needed matching sets for 60 card decks. I got 5 matching colors, 2 packs each. The only problem I had was that one of the packs was cut to fit smaller cards than Magic. Still, 450 usable sleeves for that price CANNOT be beat! Plan or ordering a few more next time as well......

  -- By Matt Derry from Henderson, KY on October 26, 2010

This is my second time ordering these sleeves. The price is awesome and got 50 count metallic sleeves in assorted colors.

  -- By Paulette A from United States of America on October 20, 2010

i never write these but since there doesn't seem to be much consensus among the reviews, i will give my experience. i bought 12 and requested in the comments section that i wanted matching sleeve packs if possible to sleeve 60 card decks and received 50 card sleeve packs in sets of 4x, 4x, 2x, and 2x. none of them were penny sleeves, and they are very reasonable for what i paid. if i ever need to buy sleeves again, i will order more of these. :)

  -- By Ted from Virginia, USA on October 16, 2010

I have ordered a combined 48 packs of these sleeves, and I must say I am quite pleased. T&T is very good at giving you at least 2 of the same sleeves when you order in bulk like I have. The first order of 20, I received 2 packs that didn't have a matching pair (which is useless for a deck of 60 cards:MTG). No big deal and I was still happy. The second order (28) I received only 1 package that didn't have a match. Overall they sent me sets of 3 matching packs for 7 patterns 2 matching packs 3 packs of penny sleeves and 1 odd ball yellow pack. The only reason I don't give them 5 stars is because in the second order they sent me those 3 packs of penny sleeves (the clear soft sleeves) and I didn't realize that it was a possibility (I use these sleeves to play with and you can't shuffle with those soft sleeves). Overall I am still pleased.

  -- By Dave M from Columbus, OH on August 04, 2010

I ordered 10 random packs of sleeves. I read the previous reviews and was thinking, "ok, I will get mostly oddball 50 packs that I can use for draft decks". I did get all 50 packs but I got 4 sets of 2 and only 2 oddball packs. As far as brands I got 4 packs of dek prot, 2 max protection, and 4 ultra pro packs. Even the cheapo dek prot sleeves are almost double the random sleeve price per pack so I am very happy with my purchase.

  -- By Nathan from Memphis, TN on June 21, 2010

I ordered 3 and got 3 100 sleeve packs.

  -- By Keir from Candy Land on June 16, 2010

Really cool deal. I ordered 5 and all 5 were Ultra-Pro. Nice stuff

  -- By Andrew Bean from TN on April 29, 2010

You guys are nuts if you say that you got gyped cuz you didn't get the 100 counts, or you didn't get enough variety or there was too much, I'm stoked cuz at very worst I just bought 800 sleeves for a good price, I'll respond again of the quality of them after I get them, but I think you guys gotta realize that this is a kick ass deal!

  -- By Jordan from illinois on March 09, 2010

i ordered 50 of these random sleeves and recieved 3 random acks of ultra pro sleeves and 47 packs asssorted cardway sleeves. its a good deal but the wide virety you use to get with this deal is gone.

  -- By vince from S.L.C., UT on February 23, 2010

I order 16 packs of these for my brother and I for Christmas. I think we got lucky but all 16 packs were 100 count cardway sleeves! It was a tremendous surprise and now we won't have to worry about sleeves for our magic decks for a very long time! Thanks TrollandToad!

  -- By stephen from Kalamazoo,Mi on January 30, 2010

Well I got 1 pack in an earlier order and got a nice cardway 100 red sleeves. So I ordered 6 more later, expecting to get some 50 count sleeves, but got all 50 count sleeves. While I expected to get 50 card sleeves (to use with the under 50 card starter sets), I hoped for some more 100 card packs. Still, it’s a good deal on sleeves, as long as you plan to get 50 count.

  -- By Garret Castle from NJ, USA on December 30, 2009

Amazing buy for atleast me. Ordered 10 packs and all were mono colors red/blue/black/gold of 100ct each. Very happy with this buy.

  -- By Thran from Texas on December 03, 2009

I have come back 3 times to buy these sleeves. These are bar none the best deal on sleeves ever sold. TrollandToad is the only place I get my game fix.

  -- By Nate Simpson from Duluth, MN USA on November 16, 2009

This would've been better if they sorted it out to YuGiOh and Regular size. Maybe artwork and no artwork too.

  -- By Afnan Zakaria from Otherside on November 06, 2009

i ordered 5 pack of sleeves and received exactlly what i wanted they came with 50 sleeves each perect for naruto and i just bought 10 more hope i didnt mess up

  -- By jabba from McAllen,TX USA on November 04, 2009

I ordered 6 sleeves, and received no duplicates. Unfortunately, every pack contained only 50 sleeves. Would have been nice to receive maybe one duplicate or a single larger pack. Still, the sleeves looked great. I was surprised that they all had nice art work rather than plain colors. I may give it one more try. Could always use with 40 card decks in draft rounds.

  -- By Gabriel from Texas on August 27, 2009

hey if they had another section for mini sleeves like for yugioh than i'd be buying i've been tinking bout buying random sleeves but concerned that when i get them they will all be standard size. pls make another area for mini random sleeves :D

  -- By albert from burlington,ON on July 06, 2009

I ordered 5 for me and my brother ordered 1, we received no duplicates which is always good, and although each only contained 50 as someone else mentioned in a Review, I got 6 different, cool packages of sleeves at a great price.

  -- By C. Moore from St. Louis, MO, USA on June 18, 2009

Cheaper than anywhere else. I bought 5 packs and got a different pack each time, including a 100 ct pack. Ordering 3 doesn't mean you will get a different count because well, Look how many they have available!

  -- By T K from That place NY on June 16, 2009

Thought i realized that it was risky, i ordered 3. i've been getting stuff here for awhile and have always gotten the best treatment. i assumed that i might get one or 2 of the min of 50, but i trusted that i'd get atleast one bunch of more then that. well, i was wrong. if you buy one of these, assume that it says.. "you will get 50".

  -- By Wes Olsen from Baltimore, MD on June 01, 2009