This card is really versatile. Except when you have a goyf in play and so does your opponent, then it kinda sucks using it because it destroys your goyf as well... but other than that, great card in most formats.

  -- By erik farnsworth from colorado on December 22, 2009

Good card but has a major weakness eg: in that you target my spectral procession token thinking you rid me off all my tokens. I simply swords / or path it to gain life/land advantage and your spell fails still apart from that will use it in my black/green deck hence the three star rating.

  -- By frank from taranaki,new zealand. on December 03, 2009

someone said that lands aren't permanents. lands are permanents this just cant destroy them. anything that stays on the battlefield after it resolves is a permanent.

  -- By Josh Earwood from Portsmouth, OH USA on October 19, 2009

Good card this card can destroy planeswalkers, creatures, enchantments, artifacts, anything that isn not a land is considered to be a permanent it in the rule book for who dont know. This card is so great it can kill alot of the same type of cards that are out at once.

  -- By Keith Roth from USA on August 19, 2009

This is one of the best cards in standard and I expect it to be better when Lorwyn/Morningtide/Shadowmoor/Eventide rotate out.

  -- By Anonymous from Maine, usa on July 21, 2009

For me it really better than Vindicate. Find your foil version before will be to late :):)

  -- By Le Pic from Qc, Canada on June 24, 2009

Planeswalkers are permenants, so it can destroy them.

  -- By Anonymous from Missouri on June 08, 2009

Someone stated that Planeswalkers were not permanents which is not true. The only issue with Planeswalkers is there will not be multiples due to the rule preventing multiples of them to exist to begin with. The card is an absolute beast, and I couldn't ask for a better removal for B/G

  -- By Anonymous from Miami, FL on June 03, 2009

Incredibly good card for just 3 mana. It cant destroy lands or planeswalkers (since they arent permanents) but tokens and certain creatures are big now, so it is definitely 5 stars

  -- By Anonymous from Advance on June 01, 2009

No matter which way I look at it, I can't think of this as better than Vindicate. Still, it is much more helpful against token decks, and occasionally regular decks, and has colors that are more geared towards acceleration. Not being able to hit lands is a pretty big flaw though, even if 9 times out of 10 you would aim for something much different. Still, this card is nothing to scoff at, much better than Creeping Mold.

  -- By Carey from Raleigh, NC USA on May 30, 2009

An amazingly versatile card. The flexibility of being able to kill a planeswalker, spectral procession tokens, solid creatures and bitterblossom makes this card simply amazing. There's nothing not to like about this card.

  -- By Supa Lfy T.N.T. from Pulp Fiction on May 03, 2009

Everyone loved Vindicate right? Well now we have echoing vindicate (Oh no it can't target lands but who cares). Now, other than the possibility of a 2 or 3 for 1 in most games, it wrecks most token decks. A downside is that it's in black-green, but anyone and everyone can splash colors these days. It's a sorcery, but it's substantially better than oblivion ring and people run that. In mirror matches you might end up killing your own permanents, which I think is the biggest drawback.

  -- By Anonymous from Hawaii on May 03, 2009

This is going to make Jund-Rock t1. just wait for it.

  -- By Vincent van Gogh from Your Vas diferens on April 30, 2009