If she 4/4 flier, then I would rate her more than 5 star. But 3/4 flier is reasonable because of her ability. I agree the guy above me. Any weenie decks or Goblin decks are no problem anymore. Just keep her alive (with some equipments like Umezawa's Jitte and Lightning Greaves) and your opponent will be beaten. For more fun, try 2 of them in play.... there'll be no big damage coming around......

  -- By Gerrard Verdict from The Vindication Place on December 19, 2010

Love this card. The price is so cheap, useful, and powerful. It's kindda funny when I play her against weenie decks because she's reducing effectiveness all opponent's creatures. 2/2 creature will be 1/1, and cards like Honor of the Pure just bring the power/toughness into normal..... It looks like not powerful if you just see it, but in the game, you will be forced to destroy her first if you want your attack effective. Some deck like goblins is not a big deal for me anymore....

  -- By Anonymous from Tower of Flame on December 15, 2010

The sight of a 3/4 Flier for 2WW may not look much, but with ability that can prevent 1 damage to you from any source will reduce damage speed from your opponent's creatures and/or the other spells.

  -- By Anonymous from ??? on June 19, 2010

As a 3/4 creature with Flying that can prevent 1 damage, this is clearly a powerhouse! Any 1/1 creatures or red damage spell will be lockdown. Use Baneslayer or Battlegrace to gain life and the game will be end quickly...

  -- By John Verdian from USA on June 12, 2010

If she's 4/4 then she's very powerful! But she's just 3/4 and the ability also elevated.

  -- By Anonymous from jakarta on June 12, 2010

This Card is great, playing against weenies, once I get two or three of these out, their shut down.

  -- By Anonymous from Boston, MA on November 23, 2009

Awesome card that fits into most white decks. Although not as strong as Baneslayer Angel, the Guardian Seraph really helps you against tokens and shooters

  -- By Jens N from Denmark on September 19, 2009